John Idington (1840-1928) was a Canadian justice of the Supreme Court of Canada who practiced law in Stratford, Ontario, initially in partnership with the Liberal politician Robert MacFarlane, and served as Crown attorney and clerk of the peace for Perth County from 1879. After roughly a year on the High Court of Justice of Ontario, Prime Minister Wilfrid Laurier appointed him to the Supreme Court to replace Justice Albert Clements Killam, and he served as a Puisne Justice from February 10, 1905 until his retirement on March 31, 1927, when Parliament amended the Supreme Court Act to set a mandatory retirement age of 75. He was described as an individualist and renegade whose judicial legacy included progressive civil rights stances in some cases, though critics considered his later jurisprudence increasingly erratic.
Facts
RoleJustice of the Supreme Court of Canada 1 Nationality / Jurisdiction Place of Death Classification
Field of LawLegal Philosophy and Jurisprudence 1 Role
Role (category) FAQs
Why did John Idington leave the Supreme Court of Canada in 1927?
He was removed on March 31, 1927, when a new mandatory retirement age of 75 came into force.
In his later years Idington's mental capacity declined, and he missed the entire 1925 spring term and nearly all of the two terms after it because of health issues. Minister of Justice Ernest Lapointe formally asked him to step down in February 1926, and he did not. In 1927 Parliament amended the Supreme Court Act to expand the Court to seven judges and to introduce a mandatory retirement age of 75. Idington was removed from office on March 31, 1927, at the age of 86, when the amendments came into force.
Connections
In Legal System
Source John Idington (Wikipedia)
Member Of
Source John Idington (Wikipedia)
In the Other Atlases
Nationality
Also in Geography Atlas: the nationality of this subject.
Source John Idington (Wikipedia)tier 2
Sources
1. John Idington (Wikipedia)
WikipediaFull article, gender
Idington was born on October 14, 1840, in Puslinch, Upper Canada (now Ontario), the eldest child of Peter Idington, a farmer, and his wife Catherine Stewart.
Introduction, nationality
John Idington (1840-1928) was a Canadian justice of the Supreme Court of Canada who practiced law in Stratford, Ontario, initially in partnership with the Liberal politician Robert MacFarlane, and served as Crown attorney and clerk of the peace for Perth County from 1879.
Justice of the Supreme Court of Canada section
Idington had only been on the Ontario bench for a year before his appointment to the Supreme Court. His appointment, which replaced the Court's only western representative with another justice from Ontario, surprised the legal community and western Canada, and prompted speculation that it was difficult to persuade judges to accept an appointment to the Supreme Court.
Full article, field of law
Ian Bushnell describes Idington as an "individualist and renegade", whose jurisprudence declined over the years eventually becoming "erratic and petty." he took a progressive civil rights approach in Quong Wing (1914) and Gray (1918).
Member Of: Supreme Court of Canada, Lead section
John Idington (October 14, 1840, February 7, 1928) was a Canadian justice of the Supreme Court of Canada.
In Legal System: Law of Canada, Wikipedia lead sentence
was a Canadian justice of the Supreme Court of Canada
View the Source 2. Wikidata: John Idington
Wikidata Q6240721, P569 date of birth claim (year)
P569 (date of birth): 1840
Wikidata Q6240721, P569 date of birth claim (full date)
P569 (date of birth): 1840-10-14
Wikidata Q6240721, P570 date of death claim (year)
P570 (date of death): 1928
Wikidata Q6240721, P570 date of death claim (full date)
P570 (date of death): 1928-02-07
Wikidata Q6240721, P19 place of birth claim
P19 (place of birth): Puslinch
Wikidata Q6240721, P20 place of death claim
P20 (place of death): Ottawa
View the SourceReader Challenges (0)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.
Sign in to dispute this or suggest a correction.